A Delhi court has dismissed a petition seeking the transfer of a cyber fraud case involving more than ₹52 lakh, observing that mere suspicion or apprehension is not sufficient to establish bias against a judicial officer. The court said that allegations of partiality must be supported by concrete material and cannot be made simply because a party is dissatisfied with a judicial order.
Transfer Plea Rejected by Patiala House Court
Principal District and Sessions Judge Vijay Kumar Dahiya at Patiala House Courts rejected the transfer petition filed by a serving woman judicial officer from Haryana and her domestic help. They had sought to transfer the hearing of the bail application of accused Deepak Vats to another judicial officer.
The case relates to an alleged cyber fraud of ₹52.81 lakh. The Delhi Police Special Cell had registered an FIR against Vats, whose bail application was being heard by Additional Sessions Judge Saurabh Partap Singh Laler.
Dispute Over Earlier Bail Order
The petitioners raised objections to certain observations made in the June 9 order rejecting the accused's earlier bail application. The Haryana judicial officer alleged that references to her personal life and identity were unnecessary and had affected her privacy and professional reputation.
She also questioned the manner in which certain digital evidence and submissions were discussed in the order. The observations were subsequently stayed by the Delhi High Court, which also permitted her identity to be masked.
Court Stresses Need for Concrete Evidence
While dismissing the transfer plea, the court observed that unsupported allegations of bias could undermine the independent functioning of the judiciary. It emphasised that a reasonable apprehension of bias must be established through circumstances supported by material evidence.
The court clarified that disagreement with judicial observations or an adverse order does not, by itself, provide sufficient grounds to shift a case to another court.
Hashtags: #DelhiState #Delhi #Court #Says #Suspicion #Alone #Cannot #Establish #Judicial #CourtSaysSuspicionAlone

