New Delhi: The Delhi High Court has delivered an important ruling on the applicability of stamp duty to agreements signed by parties in different states. The court held that the location where the first person signs an agreement cannot, by itself, determine which state's stamp duty law will apply. Instead, the deciding factor must be when the agreement becomes legally complete through the signatures required under its terms. Justice Om Prakash Shukla made the observation while deciding a dispute involving four loan agreements executed in March 2014 between companies associated with the Zee Group and Religare Finvest Limited.
Agreement Became Complete in Delhi The borrower companies had signed the agreements in Mumbai, while the lender, Religare Finvest, signed them in Delhi on the same day. The central question was whether the documents should attract stamp duty under the Maharashtra Stamp Act, 1958, or the Indian Stamp Act, 1899, as applicable in Delhi.
The court ruled that since the agreements required signatures from both the borrowers and the lender, they became legally executed only after Religare signed them in Delhi. Consequently, the Indian Stamp Act, as applicable in the national capital, would govern the documents.
First Signature Cannot Decide Tax Liability
The court observed that making stamp duty dependent on the geographical location of the first signatory could result in tax liability changing merely because someone happened to sign an agreement in a particular state. It also noted that modern commercial agreements are frequently signed electronically by parties located in different places.
The court set aside the interim arbitral award that had applied Maharashtra's stamp duty law to the agreements. It emphasised that the state imposing stamp duty must have a real and meaningful territorial connection with the instrument.
The ruling provides important guidance for businesses, lenders and parties entering into multi-state commercial agreements.
Hashtags: #DelhiState #Delhi #High #Court #Clarifies #Stamp #Duty #Rules #Multi #DelhiHighCourtClarifies

