New Delhi:
The Delhi High Court has upheld an order directing a man to undergo a DNA test to establish whether he is the biological father of a young girl, observing that a child's right to know her parentage can outweigh an alleged father's right to privacy in appropriate circumstances. A division bench of Justices Vivek Chaudhary and Renu Bhatnagar dismissed the man's appeal against the Family Court's August 2024 direction for DNA testing. The dispute arose after a woman claimed that she had married the man in 1997 and lived with him in Delhi and Gujarat. She alleged that he left her in July 2010, during which period she conceived their daughter, who was born in March 2011. The man denied the marriage, their relationship and the child's paternity, arguing that he had been married to another woman since 1999 and had two children from that marriage. The woman’s earlier petitions seeking restoration of marital rights and maintenance were dismissed in 2012 because she could not establish the marriage. However, the High Court clarified that those proceedings did not determine the girl's biological parentage and that the daughter was not a party to them. Rejecting the man's privacy argument, the bench said the right to privacy, though fundamental, is not absolute and must be balanced against the child's right to know her biological origins. The court directed that samples be collected confidentially at BSA Hospital and the DNA report sent to the Family Court in a sealed cover. It clarified that the question of actual paternity would be decided by the Family Court after examining the report and other evidence; the High Court has not declared the man to be the girl's biological father.
Hashtags: #DelhiState #Delhi #High #Court #Upholds #Dna #Test #Paternity #Dispute #DelhiHighCourtUpholds

