ITDC illustration
The distance between two schools looks different on a planning map and from the height of a small child. A merger that promises more teachers and better facilities must answer a prior question: can every affected pupil actually reach the improved school, safely and regularly?
India's National Education Policy 2020 makes the principle explicit. In describing school complexes and rationalisation, it says accessibility must not be reduced; its discussion of consolidation repeats the safeguard. Resource sharing is therefore an educational means, not permission to treat the disappearance of a nearby school as a saving in itself.
There is a serious case for consolidation. A school with too few staff may struggle to offer the range of teaching children deserve. But a better destination cannot compensate for an unworkable journey. A route assessment should examine travel time, crossings, seasonal conditions and the requirements of disabled children, rather than rely on a radius drawn around the receiving campus.
Transport promises need an operating budget, responsible provider and fallback when service fails. Families should know the arrangements before a closure becomes irreversible. Where the journey cannot be made workable, sharing specialist teachers or resources may be preferable to moving the children.
The test must continue after implementation. Attendance and transfers should be examined by age, sex and disability, with families able to report difficulties without being dismissed as resistant to reform. A decline warrants investigation, not an automatic claim that the merger caused it.
School planning should count the whole cost, including the time and expense shifted onto households. Approve a merger when learning improves and access survives. Until both can be demonstrated, the proposed efficiency remains incomplete.

